FALSE ACCOUNTS
The Old Joint Stock, Birmingham, Wednesday 19th October, 2022
You may be aware (you should be!) that since the turn of the century, hundreds of sub-postmasters up and down the country have been wrongly convicted of theft or false accounting by the Post Office. Many have lost their livelihoods, some were imprisoned. Some committed suicide. The root cause was Horizon, the computer system imposed on all branches, a system that was acclaimed as ‘infallible’. Just like the Titanic was unsinkable, it turns out.
This drama-documentary by The Outcasts Creative is dedicated to all those impacted by those real-life events. Characters of the sub-postmasters are condensed into five individuals, representing the range of experience suffered by the many. Events are linked by narration, and there are scenes that are more like sketches. Pigs’ noses and devil horns give the show an agit-prop feel, and there are some great ideas: Paula Vennells’s Darth Vader vibe, with the sub-postmasters as hooded rebels against her evil empire. There are moments when the satire is sharp, but these never undermine the emotional testimony of the monologues.
Some standouts for me include Graham MacDonnell as a jaded IT worker and later as a game-show host, and Cathy Odusanya, whose emotive account is heartbreakingly real. There is some wonderfully atmospheric music underscoring the action, courtesy of composer Ice Dob.
The cast of 13 are always on the move so its difficult to attribute roles to the correct performer on the cast list, but they make a vibrant ensemble.
Tonally, it’s patchy. The nature of the beast, I suppose, but directors Lance S A Nielsen (who also wrote it) and Dickon Tolson need to ensure energy levels are consistent across the board to keep us hooked. Also, it runs a bit long and could do with some judicious trimming: the future-in-Heaven scene is not funny enough to warrant keeping in its present form – members of the audience were ducking out, fearful of missing trains and buses. When it’s working as it should, the show contains some extremely powerful moments, amplified by the intimacy of the Old Joint Stock stage.
The story continues in the real world, as the fight for compensation goes on. It’s a story that needs to be told. People need to stop putting faith in the wrong sorts to run powerful institutions – and ought such institutions have such power without being brought to account?
Thought-provoking and moving, the show just needs a little tightening to get the bugs out.
☆ ☆ ☆ and a half!