Local Heroes


New Vic Theatre, Newcastle under Lyme, Saturday 7th April, 2012


Carrying on and celebrating the New Vic’s tradition of social documentary dramas with a strong local (North Staffordshire) identity, comes this new piece by writer Alecky Blythe and director Theresa Heskins.

The set is a stark, almost lunar, landscape.  Mounds of nutty slack and broken china house television sets.  The area’s industrial past has been superseded in this day and age.  The Potteries are now home to rife unemployment – people who stay at home and watch the telly.  I have to confess my heart sank a little when I realised the show is based around an X Factor type talent show – often the recourse of unimaginative GCSE drama groups – but my initial misgivings were quickly washed away by the style and execution of the piece.

The words spoken by the cast are all verbatim.  The people who entered the 2010 “Stoke’s Top Talent” contest provide all the dialogue in its naturalistic, often hilarious, glory.  But further to that, the production goes a step further.  The actors are wired with earpieces.  Recordings of the real people speaking the lines are played to them and the actors deliver those lines with the same inflection and intonation as close to the original speaker as possible.  The actor is the mouthpiece for the person.  While this is a peculiar way of working for the performers, isolated as they are from the atmosphere in the auditorium, it pays dividends for the audience.  As characters emerge then come and go, and we follow their experiences in the audition process, the warmth and humanity of these people shine through.

I couldn’t help thinking of Creature Comforts.

The humour, unconscious on the part of the speaker in some cases, is delightful.  “My girlfriend’s 24,” boasts a 19 year old contestant, “and she’s only got two kids.”

“Jonathan Wilkes” hosts the heats, but this contest is not about the glorification of the judges.  Neither is it about holding up the contestants to ridicule.  What comes to the fore is how important this competition is to the people of Stoke on Trent, now there is nothing else to offer them hope of bettering themselves.  The prize money of £1,000 and the chance to appear in professional panto for a month may seem small beer compared to the large-scale televised talent shows – but the contestants recognise it has a start, as a chance, a leg-up.  They go back, year after year, to try again, and they take it seriously.

You couldn’t get more of a local flavour if you sat through the show stuffing yourself with oatcakes.  But the show is much more than a local show for local people.  As an outsider to the region, I saw the national relevance of the play.  Stoke-on-Trent  becomes a microcosm for the whole country.  The obsession for these talent contests.  The death of industry.  The lack of opportunity compared to the wealth of talent and ambition.  It’s all there.  This is a state-of-the-nation piece, documenting a moment in time.  It is a celebration of the human spirit in bleak and trying times.

Theresa Heskins has collected an impressive ensemble of actors who slip in and out of a range of characters to populate the show.  Samuel Hargreaves plays 14 year old Sam, the eventual winner.  His talent and ambition are nicely counterpointed by the bathos of the slightly camp Northern bathos of his family.  The show ends with his rendition of “Let Me Entertain You” by local boy done good, Robbie Williams.  The song takes on extra significance.  The boy is at the outset of his career.  We are not told what’s become of him in the two years since his pantomime appearance.

One of my favourite actors on the planet, Michael Hugo is superb as slightly thuggish, skinhead Mark, struggling with all manner of problems and trying to stay out of trouble so he will be accepted by another means of escape from his surroundings, the armed forces.

Oliver J Hembrough evokes rather than impersonates local star-maker Jonathan Wilkes but really excels as the father in musical duo, “Lad ‘N’ Dad” – guitar, bongos and “Yummy Yummy Yummy”.

Andrew Pollard is heart-breaking as gentle charity-shop worker Graeme who can’t face the pressure of the audition process then regrets not going through with it.  Alan Bennett could write an entire show based on this man alone.

Mona Goodwin’s Kerry (runner-up in the final) displays the excitement and nervous energy and not forgetting the talent.  You really feel for her when she doesn’t win (and I knew the outcome beforehand, having seen the panto two years ago!).  Peter Temple’s pensioner Norman is finally taking his chances after a lifetime of hard work.  “Where have I been all my life?” he asks himself.  It is the line that gives the show its title, and a poignant moment about roads not taken.  Rebecca Brewer depicts a range of roles, adding to the likeability and general warmth. Angela Bain switches from middle-aged mum to ten year old little brother at the change of a shirt – the entire company proves its versatility. That is not to say this is a whitewash.  Human fallibility and the darker aspects of society are all here too.

Everyone comes out of this very well but really the show is a testament to the people of Stoke and a mirror showing what’s happening all over post-industrial Britain.  It’s more uplifting and relevant than anything Simon Cowell sticks his fingers in.


About williamstafford

Novelist (Brough & Miller, sci fi, historical fantasy) Theatre critic http://williamstaffordnovelist.wordpress.com/ http://www.amazon.co.uk/-/e/B008AD0YGO and Actor - I can often be found walking the streets of Stratford upon Avon in the guise of the Bard! View all posts by williamstafford

3 responses to “Local Heroes

  • Bryan

    Hey, thank you for that excellent and warm review. I was the original Dad in the “Lad ‘n Dad” talent show duo, and i thoroughly enjoyed the show on three occasions! The first time, i laughed myself silly at some of the ludicrous things i had said 18 months ago, whilst Alecky was recording in interview at our home in Stoke (e.g. describing my son as the “Buddy Holly of goalkeeping” because he played in his specs at that time!)

    The second time, my wife, Mary, watched with my son James (the Lad in “Lad ‘n Dad”) and all three of us gave the cast a well-deserved standing ovation, and the third time, my eldest sister drove down from Manchester to watch out of sheer curiosity! Her verdict? “Wonderfully entertaining, and thoroughly enjoyable” – not just because she saw me being sent up by my own verbal foibles, but, because she knows great theatre when she sees it!

    Whilst entertaining, i agree with you that Alecky does not avoid the harsh reality of the lives of so many who live in Stoke, and this was depicted realistically and sympathetically, in my view. Those who labelled it “patronising” were sadly either speaking out of their own brokenness, i think, or perhaps projecting their own attitudes onto the authentic portrayal of real-life characters.

    Whatever the controversy that “Where have I Been All My Life” may have aroused, i for one was delighted with the finished product, and felt very privileged to have been involved in it’s creation. To have a writer of Alecky’s talent, and Players to match, under the Directorship of Theresa Heskins, backed by her “Creatives,” in a special 50th Anniversary production, at our local theatre, was a unique and extremely memorable event that i, for one, “dunna wanna forget,” as they say here in the Potteries!

    • williamstafford

      Thank you, Bryan. I went back to see the show a second time last week and enjoyed it just as much. After the performance there was a “talkback” session in the bar. Three local dignataries gave their responses to the show and there was a discussion about some of the concerns: was it patronising? etc. The audience reassured Theresa Heskins that this was not the case, and put the dignitaries on the spot about what might be solutions to the problems highlighted by the play.

      I love the New Vic and go to see everything they put on. Perhaps we might run into each other there.

      Best wishes.

      • Bryan

        That would be excellent William. i cant get to the theatre as often as i would like these days, as i’m retired on early pensions, cos of health reasons, but i AM planning to get to “Far From The Madding Crowd” when a lot of the cast from “Where have i been all my life” will be performing, apparently. Our tickets for two of our three visits to that show were complementary, courtesy of Theresa and Alecky’s generosity.

        Thanks very much for your response/feedback. I am always delighted to hear about dignatries being put in their place, especially by the “ordinary” guy. One of my favourite all-time stories is the “Emperor’s New Clothes” where the clear vision of an innocent child reveals what is REALLY going on. Still very much a story for our times, i feel!

        take care and God bless you….Bryan.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: